In Twow BWL server firsts awarded a t-shirt. It's called Blackrock's Lord Shirt.
Hell, it's even in the octowow game files. https://octowow.st/db/?item=51857
I'm writing this post for the sole purpose of pleading you to change how Scythe of Elune is obtained.
Scythe was a notorious item in Turtle WoW due to how impossibly random it was to obtain. A piece of gear that would literally make or break your dps. A trinket to rule all ...